Transit notes on Berlin, Germany — easy does it

Bus stop with electronic sign.

Berlin bus stop with electronic sign.

On a recent trip to Berlin, I abstained from car travel and instead relied on 7 Euro (about $9) day passes to take me around town on the U-Bahn, the S-Bahn and the bus. I was seldom confused, always on time and saved tons of money. The money part was a good reminder of how expensive it is to drive anywhere. Even though Californians have ample reason to complain, in Berlin gas prices are more than twice what they are in L.A.

The ease and frequency of Berlin transit has a lot to do with the maturity of the massive system that began construction in the early 1900s. Just think what the L.A. system could look like 100 years from now.

Among factors contributing to ease of travel:

Constant updates. As studies have shown, confident travelers are happy travelers. Constant real-time arrival updates on electronic boards in S-Bahn (above ground) and U-Bahn (subway) stations and most bus stops made waiting for the next train or bus comfortable, even when the next one was 20 minutes away.

Names. Station names in Berlin tend to be utilitarian, marking locations or major sites.  Headed for the Zoo? Get off at Zoologischer Garten. Taking a trip to Potsdam? Go to Potsdam Stadt. Off to the Olympic Stadium? Head for Olympiastadion. Simplicity in names promotes clarity.

Clean. There was at least one snack shop (selling beer, of course) in each of the dozens of stations that I used or saw. Lots of people were carrying food and drink. Yet seldom was there trash on the trains or in the train stations.

berlin stick sign

Maps and signs. Train cars had electronic “next station” signs inside the cars. They also had maps that were too detailed to read in a hurry — so relatively useless — but train stations had much larger maps and (best of all) subways had pedestal signs listing stations in order of appearance on the line. So it was easy to glance at the pedestal and determine which train you should board (on which side) and to count the number of stations to your destination. Emergency signs were marked SOS … the universal sign of distress. And when there was more than one train running on the same track, clear hanging signs explained which train went where.

The honor system. Berlin trains operate without turnstiles. And like L.A., traveling controllers check that passengers have purchased tickets and issue citations to those who have not. Tickets are easily purchased with cash or credit card from machines on all train platforms and in subway stations. The machines read out in a variety of languages — as Metro’s do — and are fairly easy to follow, although it took a couple of tries to figure out the system. Tickets are sold by zones but since there are no turnstiles, this too is dependent on the honesty of the traveling public.

Shopping. Some stations — Central Station, for example — are actually destinations, containing restaurants and multi-leveled shopping malls.

Continue reading

Melbourne Metro PSA: "Dumb Ways to Die"

Metro Trains Melbourne’s latest public service advertising campaign has received a lot of attention the past few days. The song and music video related to its safety awareness campaign, “Dumb Ways to Die” have gone viral since they were first posted last week. The video amassed over 4 million views in its first few days on YouTube and the song reached the top ten on iTunes charts. Not bad considering the campaign hasn’t officially kicked off yet. Here’s a link to its website.

Continue reading

The Transit Tourist: Chicago, Ill.

The Transit Tourist takes a look at other transit systems across the globe from the first person perspective of a visitor. What can Metro learn from how these other systems treat the uninitiated – and often bumbling – tourist?

Quiet summer afternoon at Fullerton Station (Chicago, IL) Photo: Joseph Lemon/Metro

This is…The Transit Tourist – Chicago, Ill.

Chicago, Illinois
City Population: 2,695,598 Transit Agency: CTA Miles of Rail Track: 224.1
Density: 11,864 people/sq. mi. Rail Lines: 8 Bus Routes: 140
Area: 234 sq. mi. Rail Stations: 143 Op. Budget: $1.39 bil.

Source: US Census and transitchicago.com

Airport Connection

The Chicago “L” — a heavy rail system that runs both above and below ground — runs from downtown to both of the city’s major airports, O’Hare and Midway. The train and area buses are run by the Chicago Transit Authority, the region’s equivalent to Los Angeles Metro.

The Blue Line runs to the airport and takes about 45 minutes to travel to downtown Chicago. The Orange Line runs to Midway and takes about 25 minutes to reach downtown.

There is direct access to the “L” station at O’Hare from terminals 1, 2 and 3 — although like everything at O’Hare, it can involve a long walk.

Here’s a pretty useful web page on the CTA site that explains all the basics about traveling by rail to or from the airports.

Trains at Chicago O’Hare Blue Line Station (Chicago, IL) Photo: Joseph Lemon/Metro

Continue reading

The Transit Tourist: Portland, Ore.

A Portland band plays a tune on the sidewalk as a MAX light rail train passes behind. Photo by Carter Rubin/Metro.

The Transit Tourist takes a look at other transit systems across the globe from the first person perspective of a visitor. What can Metro learn from how these other systems treat the uninitiated – and often bumbling – tourist?

Last year, Fred Camino inaugurated The Transit Tourist series with an excellent post about his trip to London. To refresh, here are his thoughts on why the tourist perspective of another city’s transit system can be a valuable one for readers of The Source:

The tourist experience on transit is a unique but important one. Tourists generally have different needs than the daily commuter, but my feeling is that when a tourist’s needs are met a transit system is doing a good job at two things: providing an easy to use system that also serves many destinations. In other words, if a system works for an outsider, it’s probably going to work for local residents as well.

The next stop on our Transit Tourist adventures: Portland, Oregon! During my week-long visit to Portland, my primary agenda was to explore a city that is often held as a model of good public transportation and urban design.

I got very lucky on the weather front: six consecutive sunny days. That made touring the city on transit and foot even easier, though perhaps I didn’t quite get a representative experience of a city known for its seemingly perpetual drizzle and rain.

The good weather made Portland even more comfortable to explore on foot. Especially in downtown and its environs, the sidewalks tend to be very generous, the streets pretty narrow, and the blocks very short — all of which make the city feel more intimate and accessible. And those are all features that make it pleasant being out in public and taking transit…weather permitting.

Continue reading

Transit notes from Taipei

The Taipei MRT. Photo by Jennifer, via Flickr creative commons.

A few readers have recently asked for more posts about transit in Asia, the home to some of the planet’s most used and advanced systems.

With that in mind, I wanted to share my experience with the Taipei Metro, also known as the MRT. I was raised in the ‘burbs of Southern California but also spent three years living in Taiwan. I now work at Metro and live in downtown Los Angeles — and still find myself nostalgic at times for certain aspects of Taipei’s MRT.

The Taipei MRT currently has about 65 miles of rail above and below ground and serves metropolitan Taipei, which has a population of about 6.9 million people. In comparison, Metro Rail has over 73 miles of track in L.A. County, which has a population of about 9.8 million. The Taipei MRT has about 1.6 million people taking its rail system on weekdays compared to the 300,000 or so who are estimated to take Metro Rail each day; Taipei is also much more densely populated than sprawling L.A. County.

A few comparisons between the MRT and our Metro:

EasyCard vs. TAP. In a word, the EasyCard is awesome. It’s essentially a travel debit card that you can load up at any station or many convenience stores, such as 7-11. It’s accepted on all MRT lines and all buses within Taipei County, and you can use it to pay for bike rentals and tickets to certain tourist attractions. When I left Taiwan, a few convenience stores were starting to accept EasyCard as a form of payment, and the list has since grown. If you buy an EasyCard, you also get a 20% discount on fares — a great incentive for getting an EasyCard. Hint, hint. Continue reading

Fred's transit notes from New York City

Brooklyn Bridge - City Hall NYC subway station.

If you read my previous post, you know I’m now living in New York City and no longer a regular contributor to The Source.

I will chime in from time to time with a guest post though, and my first such post is simply a collection of observations of New York City transit in comparison to Los Angeles from the perspective of a new resident. You can read Carter’s review of the NYC transit system from the perspective of a tourist here.

  • Buses. For the most part, the buses I’ve ridden have incredible frequency during the weekday. I’m talking service every three minutes. Off peak or during the weekends I’ve definitely found myself waiting a while. Bus service is also not immune to special events. A few weeks ago the New York Marathon put bus service in disarray and there was no good information posted at bus stops. I ended up giving up on my planned bus outing since the bus I was waiting for never showed up.
  • Nextrip? Not so much. NYC MTA is currently testing real time bus arrivals for three lines, two in Manhattan and one in Brooklyn. Aside from the fact that so few lines offer real time information, the information that is provided is not so great. Bus stops do have QR codes, but they lead to a web pages that list every stop unlike Metro’s system which leads to a page specifically for the stop that was scanned. Also, the real time information provided is not given in terms of how many minutes away a bus is but instead how many stops away a bus is. I much prefer Metro’s method. Note: I’ve only tested the real time system on the Brooklyn B63 bus line.

Continue reading

The Transit Tourist: New York City, N.Y.

The Transit Tourist takes a look at other transit systems across the globe from the first person perspective of a visitor. What can Metro learn from how these other systems treat the uninitiated – and often bumbling – tourist?

I’ve had the opportunity to travel to New York City a number of times. It helps, after all, to have a brother in Brooklyn with a spare couch. But my latest trip eastwards was different for a couple reasons: 1) It was my first trip to the Big Apple since I became a transportation writer, and 2) I had yet to see a lot of the ground-level changes to the city’s transportation system, namely all the new bike lanes, bus lanes and pedestrian plazas.

So many lines! Click through for a high def PDF.

The subway? It was pretty much the same one I rode during my last trip in 2009, but it was interesting to see how it works in a new, more critical light — that of a transportation planner-in-training.

Frankly, entire books have been written about public transit in New York; there’s a lot to say about a transit system that carries a full third of all the transit trips in the U.S. So I won’t try to cover that territory. Rather, I’ll try to hone in on how the system works in comparison to public transit in L.A. County as it is today and as it will be in the near future.

Last year, Fred Camino inaugurated The Transit Tourist series with an excellent post about his trip to London. To refresh, here are his thoughts on why the tourist perspective of another city’s transit system can be a valuable one for readers of The Source:

The tourist experience on transit is a unique but important one. Tourists generally have different needs than the daily commuter, but my feeling is that when a tourist’s needs are met a transit system is doing a good job at two things: providing an easy to use system that also serves many destinations. In other words, if a system works for an outsider, it’s probably going to work for local residents as well.

So without further ado, here are my thoughts on transit in New York City using Fred’s categories.

Next stop for The Transit Tourist – New York City

New York, N.Y.
Population: 8,175,000 Transit Agency: New York Metropolitan Transportation Authority Miles of Rail Track: 659
Density: 27,532/sq. mi. Rail Lines: 24 Bus Routes: 217
Area: 304.8 sq. mile Rail Stations: 468 Budget: $8.6 billion
Source: US Census and MTA.info.

Airport Connection

Two of the three major airports serving the New York area can be reached by train plus a people mover; the other airport, LaGuardia, is served by several bus lines.

My flight to New York arrived at John F. Kennedy International Airport after 1 a.m. Typically, traveling into the city is not a problem even at that time, because most of the New York transit system runs 24 hours a day. There was a hitch, however: The AirTrain people mover that connects the airport terminals to the train system was shut down overnight for scheduled maintenance. Thankfully, a friend generously offered to pick me up in his car. Even in New York, sometimes you have to rely on a friend for a ride.

Continue reading